In 1906 Schuyler studied with Howard Pyle in Wilmington, Delaware.
Thanks to his association with Howard Pyle, Schuyler landed his first published illustration on the cover of The Saturday Evening Post, which he was soon working regularly for along with Pearson's and Munsey's Magazine
In 1916 Schuyler moved to 76 Huguenot Street in New Rochelle, New York, a prestigious artist community with neighbors such as J.
C.
Leyendecker, and Norman Rockwell.
New Rochelle was also the home of his recently deceased namesake, Frederic Remington.
After the Great war, and through the 1920s, Schuyler worked steadily doing interior illustrations for Life, St.
Nicholas and Century magazines.
He also painted cover illustrations for pulp magazines, such as Frontier Stories, Short Stories, West and Wild West Weekly.Schuyler did illustrations for Boys' Life and the Boy Scout Handbook as part of his thirty years service as a volunteer for the Boy Scouts.
Other books illustrated by Schuyler included Daniel Boone, Wilderness Scout by Stewart Edward White, Indian Hunting Grounds and Great White Buffalo.
He also was active as a mural painter and was editor of the Architectural Record for a period.
During the Depression years, he painted many covers for pulp magazines and worked as a muralist for the WPA artist's program in Connecticut.
After the end of the pulp era, Schuyler moved back to his birth state, Missouri, and taught art at Missouri Valley College.