On the evening of 8 June, during the onset of a wild storm, an attempt was made to return the landed party to the ships.
One of the ships' boats was anchored beyond the surf, and ropes were used to haul people from the shore to the boat.
Vasse, who was said to be a strong swimmer but was also said in some reports to have been drunk, was lost in the heavy surf and presumed drowned.
A number of stories subsequently emerged that claimed that Vasse had survived.
Some time between 1804 and 1807, a rumour that Vasse had survived appeared in some Paris newspapers.
Vasse was reported to have been washed ashore, walked 300 miles (480 km) south, and been picked up by an American whaler which took him as far as the English Channel.
He was then said to have been arrested by an English ship, and incarcerated in an English jail.
Moore wrote in his diary:
Some natives of that neighbourhood recollect him.
They treated him kindly and fed him but he lingered on the seacoast looking for his vessel.
He gradually became very thin from anxiety, exposure and poor diet.
At last the natives were absent for a time on a hunting expedition and on their return they found him dead on the beach, his body much swollen.Moore initially published this story in a letter to The Perth Gazette.
In 1841, Georgiana Molloy related a different story of Vasse's survival in a letter to Captain James Mangles, but gave no provenance for her version of events.
She wrote:
Dr Carr...
has undertaken to reclaim the Bones of Mons.
Vasse, the Gentm.
from who this river takes its Name.
Some society in Paris has offered a reward or present for them.
These natives know where they are, in the vicinity of Cape Naturaliste, and are now employed getting them, or for what I know, have got them.
This event happened about thirty years since; this unfortunate Gentm.
came in shore to explore, was seized, strangled and the spear went in at the right side of the heart.